Looking Beyond the DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The deervalley compact round white toilet alternatives list helps you find fixtures that match its space-saving design. This original model offers a 24.6-inch length and dual-flush efficiency for tight bathrooms. You might look elsewhere if you need an elongated bowl or a different seat height. Some buyers prefer ADA-compliant seating or quieter soft-close seats. Others want a specific color or a different brand reputation. These alternatives were chosen because their specs overlap with the original. Each option shares key features like one-piece construction and 12-inch rough-in size. You can compare dimensions and flush volumes to find the best fit. This guide covers 6 options that prioritize similar practical benefits. You get to choose based on your specific bathroom constraints. Whether you need extra comfort or a budget-friendly choice, the data shows clear differences. We focus on what each product delivers in terms of size and function. Your decision should depend on which specifications matter most for your space. The following sections break down the details for each alternative. You will see how each model compares to the DeerValley unit. This approach ensures you make an informed choice based on facts.
How these alternatives compare
BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet
The BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet shares the one-piece design and dual-flush system of the DeerValley model. It offers a slightly larger footprint at 25.6 inches long and 14.8 inches wide. This extra width may provide more stability. Both units maintain ADA chair height for comfortable seating. The BAYROLL model weighs 93 pounds, making it heavier than the DeerValley option. You choose this alternative if you prefer a wider base for small bathrooms. It retains the same water-saving 1.1/1.6 GPF efficiency. The modern aesthetic aligns with the original, but the increased dimensions suit users who need a bit more room around the fixture.
HOROW Compact One Piece White Toilet
The HOROW Compact One Piece White Toilet is 0.4 inches longer than the DeerValley model. It also features a dual-flush system and one-piece construction. This unit includes a soft-close seat, similar to the DeerValley quiet operation. The HOROW toilet is slightly wider at 13.4 inches. It weighs 90 pounds, offering a sturdy build. You might pick this alternative if you prioritize a marginally larger bowl in a compact space. The seat height matches the ADA standard of the original. Both models target small bathrooms with modern designs. The HOROW option provides comparable cleaning ease through its skirted design. It is a solid choice for those who want a familiar footprint with slight dimensional variations.
DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet
The DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet shares the same 24.6-inch length and 13-inch width as the original round model. The key difference is the seat height. This budget version offers standard height seating, whereas the original provides ADA chair height. It maintains the dual-flush efficiency and one-piece design. This unit is lighter at 78 pounds compared to the 86-pound original. You should select this alternative if you prefer a lower seat height. It is ideal for users who do not need the ergonomic benefits of ADA compliance. The compact dimensions remain identical, ensuring it fits the same tight spaces. It offers the same water-saving benefits but targets a different user preference for seat height.
DeerValley DV-1F52508 Elongated One-Piece
The DeerValley DV-1F52508 Elongated One-Piece Toilet differs primarily in bowl shape. It features an elongated bowl instead of the round shape found in the original. This adds 2 inches to the length, measuring 26.6 inches deep. The width is also slightly wider at 14.4 inches. It retains the ADA chair height and dual-flush system. This model weighs 97 pounds, making it the heaviest in this comparison. You choose this alternative if you want the comfort of an elongated bowl in a small bathroom. The increased depth requires more clearance. It offers the same easy-clean one-piece design and water efficiency. It is best for users who prioritize seating comfort over maximum space savings.
HOROW T0338W ADA Height One-Piece Toilet
The HOROW T0338W ADA Height One-Piece Toilet is an elongated model with a 26.6-inch length. It shares the ADA chair height and dual-flush system of the original. However, it is significantly wider at 15 inches and heavier at 99.2 pounds. This unit is designed for small bathrooms but offers more bowl space. You might prefer this alternative if you need ADA compliance with an elongated shape. The increased width and length provide a larger footprint. It maintains the one-piece design for easy cleaning. The dual-flush efficiency matches the original model. This option suits users who want accessibility features but are willing to accept a larger size for added comfort.
Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet
The Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet is an elongated model with a 27-inch length. It offers ADA chair height and dual-flush efficiency similar to the original. This unit is wider at 15.2 inches and taller at 31.3 inches. It is also the heaviest option at 109 pounds. The glossy white finish provides a sleek look. You should choose this alternative if you need an elongated bowl with ADA height. The increased dimensions require more bathroom space. It retains the one-piece design for simple maintenance. The dual-flush system ensures water efficiency. This model is ideal for users who prioritize comfort and accessibility over the compact footprint of the original round toilet.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet
Best for: small bathrooms needing space-saving round toilets
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12''
- Bowl Shape
- round
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
- Design Style
- Modern
- Target Space
- Small Bathrooms
View on Amazon: DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet Affiliate link
This DeerValley one-piece toilet measures 24.6 inches long and 13 inches wide, making it a strong candidate for small bathrooms. It features a round bowl and dual-flush system with 1.1/1.6 GPF options. The unit weighs 86 pounds and includes a soft-close seat. You get a fully skirted design for easier cleaning. It fits standard 12-inch rough-ins.
Pros
- Compact 24.6-inch length saves floor space
- Dual flush saves up to 16,500 gallons annually
- Fully skirted design hides plumbing for easy cleaning
- Includes soft-close seat for quiet operation
Cons
- Round bowl shape is less common than elongated
- Standard height may be less comfortable for some users
- 12-month warranty is shorter than industry standards
Good fit if
- You have a small bathroom with tight clearance
- You prefer a round bowl for space efficiency
- You want a fully skirted design for easy maintenance
Skip if
- You need an elongated bowl for extra comfort
- You require a chair-height seat for accessibility
- You prefer a longer warranty period
Verdict: DeerValley Compact Round Toilet fits small bathrooms well with its 24.6-inch length and dual-flush efficiency. It suits buyers prioritizing space savings and easy cleaning over elongated bowl comfort.
BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet
Best for: ADA-compliant small bathroom installations
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 0.9/1.28 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12 inch
- Seat Height
- 17 inch
- Bowl Shape
- round
- MaP Flush Score
- 1000g
View on Amazon: BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet Affiliate link
This one-piece toilet features a round bowl and 17-inch ADA-compliant seat height for ergonomic comfort. It uses a dual-flush system with 0.9 GPF and 1.28 GPF options to conserve water. The compact 25.6-inch length suits small bathrooms, while the 1000g MaP score indicates strong flushing power. Gold, white, or matte black finishes are available.
Pros
- 17-inch ADA chair height for easier sitting and standing
- Dual flush options at 0.9 GPF and 1.28 GPF
- 1000g MaP flush score for effective waste removal
- Compact 25.6-inch length fits tight spaces
- Soft-close seat with quick-release hinges
Cons
- Round bowl shape limits seating surface area
- Requires a professional plumber for installation
- Gold button finish may not match all decors
Good fit if
- You need a seat height that meets ADA standards
- You want a compact toilet for a small bathroom
- You prefer a modern one-piece design with skirted sides
Skip if
- You require an elongated bowl for more comfort
- You plan to install the toilet yourself without help
- You want a standard 15-inch rough-in size
Verdict: BAYROLL Modern Round Toilet, 17" ADA Height offers strong flushing performance and ergonomic seating in a compact footprint. It is ideal for users who prioritize ADA compliance and water efficiency in smaller bathrooms.
HOROW Compact One Piece White Toilet
Best for: small bathrooms needing quiet operation
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 gallons
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- 16.5-inch
- Bowl Shape
- round
- Toilet Type
- one piece
View on Amazon: HOROW Compact One Piece White Toilet Affiliate link
The HOROW HWMT-8733 is a one-piece compact toilet designed for small bathrooms. It measures 25 inches in depth and features a 16.5-inch seat height. This model includes a dual flush system with 1.1 and 1.6 gallon options. The fully glazed bowl aids in cleaning. It comes with a soft closing seat for quiet operation. This unit suits users prioritizing space efficiency and gentle closure.
Pros
- Compact 25-inch depth optimizes small bathroom space
- 16.5-inch seat height aids standing up
- Dual flush offers 1.1 or 1.6 gallon options
- Soft closing seat reduces noise
Cons
- Round bowl shape saves space but is less common
- 16.5-inch height is below standard ADA 17-inch requirement
- Standard 12-inch rough-in limits installation flexibility
Good fit if
- You need a toilet for a small bathroom
- You prefer a quiet soft closing seat
- You want a compact one-piece design
Skip if
- You require ADA compliant 17-inch height
- You need an elongated bowl shape
- Your bathroom has a non-standard rough-in size
Verdict: HOROW HWMT-8733 Compact Round Toilet fits small bathrooms needing a quiet, space-saving fixture with a comfortable seat height.
DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet
Best for: small bathrooms needing compact dimensions
- Flush Type
- Dual Flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Bowl Shape
- round
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
- Target Space
- Small Bathrooms
View on Amazon: DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
This DeerValley compact toilet measures 24.6 inches long and 13 inches wide. It features a one-piece design with a round bowl and dual flush system. The flush volumes are 1.1 and 1.6 GPF. It includes a soft-close seat and comes with a 12-month warranty. This model suits small bathrooms where space is limited. It offers water efficiency without sacrificing flushing power.
Pros
- Compact dimensions of 24.6"L x 13"W fit tight spaces
- Dual flush system uses 1.1/1.6 GPF for water savings
- One-piece skirted design simplifies cleaning
- Includes soft-close seat operating at 28dB
Cons
- Standard seat height may be less comfortable for some users
- Round bowl shape is less common than elongated styles
- 12-month warranty is shorter than industry standards
Good fit if
- You have a small bathroom with limited floor space
- You prefer a compact one-piece toilet design
- You want water-efficient dual flush technology
Skip if
- You require an elongated bowl for extra comfort
- You need ADA-compliant chair height seating
- You prefer a longer warranty period
Verdict: DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet is a space-saving solution for small bathrooms. It fits buyers who prioritize compact dimensions and water efficiency over elongated bowl comfort.
DeerValley DV-1F52508 Elongated One-Piece
Best for: small bathrooms needing elongated comfort
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Bowl Shape
- elongated
- MaP Flush Score
- 1000g
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
- Color
- White
View on Amazon: DeerValley DV-1F52508 Elongated One-Piece Affiliate link
The DeerValley DV-1F52508 is a compact, one-piece elongated toilet designed for smaller bathrooms. It features a dual-flush system using 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. The unit measures 26.63 inches deep and 14.37 inches wide. It includes a soft-closing seat and a seamless skirt for easy cleaning. This model offers a high MaP score for effective waste removal.
Pros
- Compact 26.63-inch depth saves space in small rooms
- Dual flush options at 1.1 and 1.6 GPF
- High 1000g MaP flush score ensures strong performance
- Seamless full-skirt design simplifies cleaning
Cons
- Standard seat height may be less comfortable for some users
- Heavier 97-pound build requires careful handling during installation
- Elongated bowl extends further into the room than round fronts
Good fit if
- You need a toilet that fits in a tight footprint
- You want a quiet, soft-closing seat for night use
- You prefer a seamless design that is easy to wipe down
Skip if
- You require a round-front bowl for maximum space savings
- You need a chair-height seat for easier standing
- You prefer a lighter unit for easier DIY installation
Verdict: DeerValley DV-1F52508 One-Piece Toilet is a solid choice for small bathrooms where space is tight but elongated comfort is still desired. It suits buyers who value easy maintenance and efficient water use.
HOROW T0338W ADA Height One-Piece Toilet
Best for: Small bathrooms needing ADA-compliant seating
- Flush Type
- Dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- 17.3"
- Bowl Shape
- Elongated
- MaP Flush Score
- 1000g
View on Amazon: HOROW T0338W ADA Height One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
This compact one-piece toilet features an elongated bowl and ADA-compliant 17.3-inch seat height. It uses a dual-flush system with 1.1 or 1.6 GPF options to balance water savings and performance. The unit measures 26.6 inches deep and includes a soft-close seat. It is designed for small bathrooms and offers easy cleaning due to its seamless construction.
Pros
- ADA chair height of 17.3 inches for easier sitting and standing
- Dual flush options of 1.1 and 1.6 GPF for water efficiency
- Compact 26.6-inch depth fits small bathroom layouts
- Seamless one-piece design simplifies exterior wiping and cleaning
Cons
- Heavier build at 99.2 pounds may complicate handling during installation
- Standard 12-inch rough-in size limits compatibility with 10-inch layouts
- Elongated bowl shape may not suit users preferring compact round bowls
Good fit if
- You need ADA-compliant seating for better accessibility
- You have a small bathroom requiring a compact footprint
- You want to reduce water usage with dual-flush options
Skip if
- You require a 10-inch rough-in size
- You prefer a round bowl over an elongated design
- You need a lighter unit for easier solo installation
Verdict: HOROW T0338W ADA Height One-Piece Toilet suits users prioritizing accessibility and space efficiency in tight bathrooms. Its ADA height and compact depth make it a practical option for small spaces.
Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet
Best for: ADA height needs and water efficiency
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Bowl Shape
- elongated
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
- Seat Height
- ADA Chair Height
View on Amazon: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
This one-piece elongated toilet features a dual vortex flush system that uses 1.1 gallons per flush for efficiency and 1.6 gallons for capacity. It sits at ADA chair height for easier access. The glossy white ceramic is scratch-resistant and non-porous. With a standard 12-inch rough-in, it fits most bathrooms. It weighs 109 pounds and measures 27 inches long.
Pros
- Dual vortex flush for effective cleaning
- ADA chair height for comfort
- Elongated bowl for extra space
- Scratch-resistant non-porous ceramic
Cons
- Heavy at 109 pounds
- Standard 12-inch rough-in only
- Elongated shape requires more space
Good fit if
- You need ADA height accessibility
- You want water-efficient dual flushing
- You prefer elongated bowl comfort
Skip if
- You have limited bathroom space
- You require a compact round bowl
- You cannot handle heavy fixtures
Verdict: Swiss Madison St. Tropez Comfort Height Toilet offers reliable ADA height and efficient dual flushing for users prioritizing accessibility and water savings in a standard layout.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet | BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet | HOROW Compact One Piece White Toilet | DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet | DeerValley DV-1F52508 Elongated One-Piece | HOROW T0338W ADA Height One-Piece Toilet | Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flush Type | not stated | dual flush | dual flush | Dual Flush | dual flush | Dual flush | dual flush |
| Flush Volume | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 0.9/1.28 GPF | 1.1/1.6 gallons | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF |
| Rough-In Size | 12'' | 12 inch | 12" | 12" | not stated | 12" | 12" |
| Seat Height | not stated | 17 inch | 16.5-inch | not stated | not stated | 17.3" | not stated |
| Bowl Shape | round | round | round | round | elongated | Elongated | elongated |
| MaP Flush Score | not stated | 1000g | not stated | not stated | 1000g | 1000g | not stated |
| Toilet Type | one-piece | one-piece | one piece | one-piece | one-piece | One-piece | one-piece |
| Design Style | Modern | Modern | Modern | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Target Space | Small Bathrooms | Small Bathrooms | Small Bathrooms | Small Bathrooms | not stated | Small Bathrooms | not stated |
| Included Components | not stated | not stated | Soft Close Seat | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Color | White | Gold Button 12 Inch Rough In | White | White with Black Button and Standard Height | White | White with Chrome Button | Glossy White |
| Shape | not stated | Round | not stated | not stated | Elongated | Elongated | Elongated |
| Design | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece |
| Dimensions | 24.6 × 13 × 27.8 inches | 25.6 × 14.8 × 27 inches | 25 × 13.4 × 28.4 inches | 24.6 × 13 × 27.8 inches | 26.6 × 14.4 × 27.1 inches | 26.6 × 15 × 26 inches | 27 × 15.2 × 31.3 inches |
| Weight | 86 pounds | 93 pounds | 90 pounds | 78 pounds | 97 pounds | 99.2 pounds | 109 pounds |
| Size | 12" Rough-In | not stated | 12" Rough-in | 12" Rough-In | 26.63"D x 14.37"W x 27.07"H | 12" Rough-in | 12" Rough-in |
| Model | DV-2F52531 | SH-S001 | HWMT-8733 | DV-1F52812 | DV-1F52508 | T0338W | SM-1T254 |
Frequently asked questions
Does the BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet fit standard rough-in sizes?
Yes, the BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet is designed for a 12-inch rough-in size. This standard dimension ensures compatibility with most residential bathroom plumbing setups. You can install it without needing to modify your existing pipe spacing. The 12-inch rough-in is the most common specification for US homes, making this a straightforward swap for many users.
Is the HOROW HWMT-8733 suitable for users who prefer quiet operation?
Yes, the HOROW HWMT-8733 includes a soft-close seat. This feature prevents the lid from slamming shut, reducing noise significantly. It is ideal for small bathrooms where echoes are common or for households with early risers. The soft-close mechanism adds a layer of comfort and reduces wear on the seat hinges over time.
Which alternative offers an elongated bowl for extra comfort?
The DeerValley DV-1F52508 and the Swiss Madison St. Tropez both feature elongated bowls. The DeerValley model measures 26.6 inches in length, while the Swiss Madison is 27 inches long. Elongated bowls provide more room for users compared to round fronts. These options are best if you prioritize comfort over maximum space savings.
Do these compact toilets support ADA chair height seating?
Several models support ADA chair height for better accessibility. The BAYROLL, HOROW T0338W, Swiss Madison St. Tropez, and the primary DeerValley round toilet all offer this height. Standard height toilets, like the budget DeerValley one-piece, sit lower. ADA height typically measures around 17 to 19 inches, making it easier to sit and stand.
Are all these toilets one-piece designs for easier cleaning?
Yes, every listed alternative uses a one-piece design. This means the tank and bowl are fused into a single unit. There are no seams between the tank and bowl to collect dust or grime. This construction simplifies wiping down the fixture and reduces maintenance efforts compared to traditional two-piece toilets.
Which model is the lightest for easier handling during installation?
The DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet (DV-1F52812) is the lightest at 78 pounds. The primary DeerValley round toilet follows closely at 86 pounds. Heavier models, like the Swiss Madison St. Tropez, weigh 109 pounds. Lighter units are easier to maneuver into tight bathroom spaces and may require less assistance during the installation process.
Do these toilets use dual-flush systems for water efficiency?
Yes, all listed models utilize dual-flush systems. This technology allows you to choose between a lower-volume flush for liquids and a higher-volume flush for solids. Dual-flush toilets generally conserve more water than traditional single-flush models. This feature helps reduce water usage without compromising cleaning performance.