6 Best Alternatives to the Swiss Madison St. Tropez Comfort Height (2026)
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The Swiss Madison St. Tropez Comfort Height toilet features an elongated one-piece design with ADA-compliant seating. If you are researching swiss madison st tropez comfort height alternatives, you may need different dimensions or flush mechanisms. This model offers a standard 12-inch rough-in and dual-flush efficiency. Its height of 31.3 inches provides accessible comfort for many users. However, its width of 15.2 inches and length of 27 inches may not fit every small bathroom layout. Some buyers might prefer a more compact footprint or a different color option like matte black.
The 6 alternatives listed here share key specifications with the original. They also feature one-piece construction and ADA-height seats. You will find options with narrower widths for tighter spaces. Some models use air-pressure flushing for stronger performance. Others offer standard height instead of ADA compliance. Each choice overlaps with the St. Tropez in core functionality. You can select based on your specific rough-in size or aesthetic preference. The list covers various brands and designs. This ensures you find a suitable replacement that matches your bathroom requirements.
Our top pick: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet.
How these alternatives compare
HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet
The HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet shares the one-piece design and dual-flush mechanism of the St. Tropez model. It also offers ADA-compliant seating height. The key difference is its compact footprint. With a length of 26.6 inches and a width of 15 inches, it is slightly smaller than the 27-inch long Swiss Madison unit. This makes it a better fit for tight spaces. The weight is lighter at 99.2 pounds. You get accessible height without the extra bulk. If your bathroom has limited floor space, this compact frame provides the same ADA benefits in a tighter layout.
DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet
The DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet matches the St. Tropez in having an elongated bowl and dual-flush system. It also maintains the ADA chair height and one-piece construction. However, the DeerValley model is lighter at 95 pounds. Its length is 28 inches, which is one inch longer than the Swiss Madison. The width is narrower at 14.2 inches. This narrower profile can help with clearance in tighter rooms. You retain the easy cleaning benefits of a one-piece design. The trade-off is a slightly longer projection. Choose this if you need ADA height but prefer a narrower toilet for better maneuverability.
BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet
The BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet differs significantly by using a round bowl shape instead of the elongated design found in the St. Tropez. It retains the one-piece build, dual-flush operation, and ADA height. The most notable change is the reduced length. At 25.6 inches, it is shorter than the 27-inch Swiss Madison model. This saves space in small bathrooms. The weight is also lower at 93 pounds. You give up the extra room an elongated bowl provides. This model suits users who prioritize compact dimensions over bowl shape. It offers ADA compliance in a smaller footprint for secondary or tight primary baths.
DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece
The DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece toilet diverges by offering standard height rather than ADA-compliant seating. It keeps the one-piece design and dual-flush mechanism. The bowl shape is not specified, but the dimensions are more compact. At 24.6 inches long and 13 inches wide, it is significantly smaller than the St. Tropez. It is also much lighter at 78 pounds. The high-gloss black finish provides a different aesthetic compared to the glossy white Swiss Madison. You sacrifice accessible height for a smaller, darker option. This model is ideal for users who do not need ADA compliance and want a space-saving, modern look.
Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece
The Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece toilet uses a different flush technology. It employs air-pressure flushing instead of the dual-flush water system found in the St. Tropez. It maintains the one-piece design and ADA chair height. The bowl is elongated, matching the St. Tropez shape. The dimensions are distinct, with a width of 15 inches and a length of 26.9 inches. The height specification in the data is 19.3 inches, which likely refers to the tank or bowl height excluding the seat. You get powerful, non-electric flushing. This option suits those who prioritize flush strength and ADA access over the specific dual-flush water efficiency of the original.
HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece Toilet
The HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece Toilet shares the elongated bowl, one-piece design, and dual-flush mechanism of the St. Tropez. It also fits a standard 12-inch rough-in. The key difference is its width. At 14 inches wide, it is narrower than the 15.2-inch Swiss Madison model. The length is 28.8 inches, making it longer. The weight is 101 pounds, which is slightly lighter. You gain a narrower profile for tighter side-to-side clearance. The trade-off is a longer projection into the room. This model is best for small bathrooms where width is the primary constraint. It offers similar ADA-adjacent comfort and efficient flushing in a slimmer frame.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet
Best for: ADA-accessible bathrooms with standard rough-ins
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Bowl Shape
- elongated
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
- Seat Height
- ADA Chair Height
View on Amazon: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
This one-piece toilet features an elongated bowl and ADA-compliant 17.3-inch seat height. It uses a dual vortex flush system with 1.1 GPF and 1.6 GPF options. The glossy white ceramic is scratch-resistant and non-porous. It fits standard 12-inch rough-ins. You get a durable, space-efficient design for accessible bathrooms.
Pros
- ADA chair height seat at 17.3 inches
- Dual vortex flush with 1.1/1.6 GPF options
- One-piece elongated bowl design
- Scratch-resistant non-porous ceramic construction
Cons
- Heavy at 109 pounds
- Standard elongated bowl shape
- Limited to 12-inch rough-in size
Good fit if
- You need ADA-compliant seating height
- You want a one-piece design
- You have a standard 12-inch rough-in
Skip if
- You require a compact elongated bowl
- You need a 10-inch rough-in
- You prefer a two-piece toilet
Verdict: Swiss Madison St. Tropez Comfort Height offers a durable one-piece build with accessible seating. It suits those prioritizing ADA height and efficient dual flushing in a standard layout.
HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet
Best for: small bathrooms needing ADA height
- Flush Type
- Dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- 17.3"
- Bowl Shape
- Elongated
- MaP Flush Score
- 1000g
View on Amazon: HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet Affiliate link
The HOROW T0338WG is a one-piece elongated toilet with a 17.3-inch ADA-compliant seat height. It features a dual-flush system using 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. The gold-plated top button adds a distinct look. Its compact 26.6-inch depth fits smaller bathrooms. The skirted trapway simplifies cleaning. This model suits those needing accessible height and water efficiency.
Pros
- 17.3-inch ADA-compliant seat height
- Dual flush with 1.1/1.6 GPF options
- Skirted trapway for easy cleaning
- Soft-closing PP seat included
- Compact 26.6-inch length
Cons
- Gold button finish may not match all decor
- 1-year limited warranty is shorter than lifetime coverage
- Standard seat height is not available in this model
Good fit if
- You need ADA-compliant seating height
- You want a compact one-piece design
- You prefer dual-flush water savings
Skip if
- You require a standard 15.5-inch seat height
- You prefer a chrome or black button finish
- You need a longer warranty than one year
Verdict: HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet offers accessible height and efficient flushing in a compact frame, making it ideal for small bathrooms requiring ADA compliance.
DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet
Best for: Users needing ADA height and easy cleaning
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- 17 3/8"
- Bowl Shape
- elongated
- MaP Flush Score
- 800g
View on Amazon: DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
The DeerValley DV-1F026 is a one-piece elongated toilet with a 17 3/8-inch seat height. It uses a dual flush system for 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. The MaP score is 800g. This design features a skirted surface for easy cleaning. You will appreciate the durable ceramic construction and 12-inch rough-in fit. It suits those needing ADA-compliant height and efficient water use.
Pros
- 17 3/8-inch ADA-compliant seat height
- Dual flush system with 1.1/1.6 GPF options
- 800g MaP flush score
- Skirted one-piece design for easy cleaning
Cons
- 95-pound weight makes handling difficult
- Standard seat height option is not available for this specific SKU
- No smart features or bidet functions listed
Good fit if
- You need an ADA-compliant seat height
- You want a skirted design for easier cleaning
- You require a 12-inch rough-in size
Skip if
- You prefer a two-piece toilet design
- You need a standard 15-inch rough-in size
- You want a compact 10-inch rough-in option
Verdict: DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet offers reliable flushing and accessible height for users who prioritize ease of maintenance and ADA compliance.
BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet
Best for: small bathrooms needing ADA height
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 0.9/1.28 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12 inch
- Seat Height
- 17 inch
- Bowl Shape
- round
- MaP Flush Score
- 1000g
View on Amazon: BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet Affiliate link
This BayRoll one-piece toilet features a 17-inch ADA chair height seat and a dual-flush system offering 0.9 or 1.28 GPF. It has a round bowl and a compact footprint measuring 25.6 inches long. The unit includes a soft-close seat and a gold-button finish option. It suits small bathrooms or secondary spaces where space efficiency matters. The 1000g MaP score indicates strong flushing power.
Pros
- 17-inch ADA chair height for ergonomic comfort
- Dual flush options at 0.9 and 1.28 GPF
- High MaP flush score of 1000g
- Compact 25.6-inch length saves space
Cons
- Round bowl shape is less common than elongated
- Gold button finish may not match all decors
- Excludes water supply pipe and floor flange
Good fit if
- You need a compact toilet for a small bathroom
- You prefer ADA height for easier sitting
- You want high-efficiency water savings
Skip if
- You require an elongated bowl for comfort
- You want a standard white finish only
- You prefer a taller than 17-inch seat
Verdict: BayRoll 17" ADA One-Piece Toilet offers a space-saving design with strong flushing performance. It fits buyers who prioritize compact dimensions and ADA height in a secondary bathroom.
DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece
Best for: small bathrooms needing standard height
- Flush Type
- Dual Flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- 16.5"
- Bowl Shape
- round
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
View on Amazon: DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece Affiliate link
This DeerValley one-piece toilet features a high-gloss black finish and a compact design suited for small bathrooms. It has a standard 16.5-inch seat height and a dual flush system with 1.1/1.6 GPF options. The fully skirted bowl and soft-closing seat simplify cleaning and reduce noise. It fits standard 12-inch rough-in spaces and weighs 78 pounds.
Pros
- High-gloss black finish resists smudges
- Fully skirted design for easy cleaning
- Soft-closing seat prevents noise
- Compact round bowl saves space
Cons
- Standard 16.5-inch height is lower than ADA options
- Round bowl shape saves space but offers less comfort
- Heavier at 78 pounds due to solid build
Good fit if
- You need a toilet for a small bathroom
- You prefer a standard seat height
- You want a modern black aesthetic
Skip if
- You require ADA comfort height seating
- You need an elongated bowl for more room
- You prefer a white porcelain finish
Verdict: DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece is a space-saving option for small bathrooms with standard height needs. It suits buyers who prioritize easy cleaning and a dark, modern look over ADA compliance.
Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece
Best for: ADA accessible bathrooms needing powerful non-electric flush
- Flush Type
- Air-pressure assisted
- Flush Volume
- 1.0 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- 17.2"
- Bowl Shape
- Elongated
- MaP Flush Score
- 1000g
View on Amazon: Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece Affiliate link
The Casta Diva is a one-piece elongated toilet with a 17.2-inch ADA height seat. It uses a non-electric air-pressure-assisted flush for strong performance. The unit saves water with a 1.0 GPF flow rate and earns a 1000g MaP score. It includes a soft-close seat and skirted base. This white model fits standard 12-inch rough-ins and requires no electricity.
Pros
- Air-pressure-assisted flush delivers powerful siphon action
- 17.2-inch ADA compliant seat height
- 1.0 GPF water-efficient dual-flush system
- 1000g MaP flush score for effective waste removal
- Includes soft-close seat and pre-installed hardware
Cons
- Air-pressure system may produce louder noise than gravity models
- Foot-kick sensor requires batteries or power source not listed
- 17.2-inch height exceeds standard 15-inch seats for some users
Good fit if
- You need ADA compliant height for easier sitting and standing
- You want a powerful flush without electric plumbing
- You prefer a skirted, one-piece design for easy cleaning
Skip if
- You require a quiet gravity-flush toilet
- You have a non-standard rough-in size
- You prefer a standard 15-inch seat height
Verdict: Casta Diva 17.2" ADA Air-Pressure Toilet offers strong flushing power and ADA height without electricity. It suits users who prioritize accessibility and water efficiency over quiet operation.
HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece Toilet
Best for: small bathrooms with 12-inch rough-ins
- Flush Type
- Dual Flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Bowl Shape
- Elongated
- MaP Flush Score
- 800g
- Toilet Type
- One-piece
View on Amazon: HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
The HOROW HR-ST076WD is a one-piece toilet designed for small bathrooms. It measures 14 inches wide and 28.75 inches deep, fitting 12-inch rough-ins. The elongated bowl offers chair-height seating at 17.3 inches. It uses a dual-flush system with 1.1 GPF and 1.6 GPF options. The skirted design hides the trapway for easier cleaning. This model includes a soft-close seat and hardware for installation.
Pros
- Compact 14-inch width saves space in small rooms
- Skirted design conceals trapway for easier cleaning
- Dual-flush options of 1.1 GPF and 1.6 GPF
- Includes soft-close seat and stainless-steel hinges
Cons
- Heavier at 101 pounds, requiring more handling effort
- Standard white finish only available in this listing
- Requires professional installation for best results
Good fit if
- You have a small bathroom or powder room
- You need a 12-inch rough-in size
- You prefer an elongated bowl for comfort
Skip if
- You require a standard height seat
- You need a 10-inch rough-in size
- You want a taller model over 28 inches
Verdict: HOROW HR-ST076WD Compact Elongated Toilet fits small bathrooms with 12-inch rough-ins. It offers space-saving width and water-efficient flushing for practical daily use.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet | HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet | DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet | BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet | DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece | Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece | HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece Toilet |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flush Type | dual flush | Dual flush | dual flush | dual flush | Dual Flush | Air-pressure assisted | Dual Flush |
| Flush Volume | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 0.9/1.28 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.0 GPF | 1.1/1.6 GPF |
| Rough-In Size | 12" | 12" | 12" | 12 inch | 12" | 12" | 12" |
| Seat Height | not stated | 17.3" | 17 3/8" | 17 inch | 16.5" | 17.2" | not stated |
| Bowl Shape | elongated | Elongated | elongated | round | round | Elongated | Elongated |
| MaP Flush Score | not stated | 1000g | 800g | 1000g | not stated | 1000g | 800g |
| Toilet Type | one-piece | One-piece | one-piece | one-piece | one-piece | One-piece | One-piece |
| Design Style | not stated | not stated | not stated | Modern | not stated | Modern | not stated |
| Target Space | not stated | Small Bathrooms | not stated | Small Bathrooms | Small Bathrooms | not stated | Small Bathrooms |
| Color | Glossy White | White with Gold Button | White with Chrome Button and ADA Height | Gold Button 12 Inch Rough In | High Gloss Black with Chrome Button and Standard Height | White | Standard White with Dual Flush |
| Shape | Elongated | not stated | Elongated | Round | not stated | Elongated | Elongated |
| Design | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece | One Piece |
| Dimensions | 27 × 15.2 × 31.3 inches | 26.6 × 15 × 26 inches | 28 × 14.2 × 26.8 inches | 25.6 × 14.8 × 27 inches | 24.6 × 13 × 27.8 inches | 26.9 × 15 × 19.3 inches | 28.8 × 14 × 28 inches |
| Weight | 109 pounds | 99.2 pounds | 95 pounds | 93 pounds | 78 pounds | not stated | 101 pounds |
| Size | 12" Rough-in | 12" Rough-in | 12" Rough In | not stated | 12" Rough-In | not stated | 12" rough in |
| Model | SM-1T254 | T0338WG | DV-1F026 | SH-S001 | DV-1F52812 | CD-W001 | HR-ST076WD |
If you require different dimensions for your space, compare swiss madison voltaire 60 x 30 alternatives to match your layout.
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative offers the most compact design for small bathrooms?
The DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece is the most compact option listed. It measures 13 inches in width and 24.6 inches in length. This model also features standard height seating rather than ADA compliance. Its high gloss black finish provides a modern look for tight spaces.
Are there alternatives with ADA-compliant seating heights?
Yes, several models offer ADA-compliant seating. The HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet, DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet, BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet, and Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece all provide chair height seating. These options ensure accessible seating for users who require higher toilet bowls.
Do these alternatives use dual-flush mechanisms like the St. Tropez?
Most alternatives use dual-flush systems for water efficiency. The HOROW T0338WG, DeerValley Elongated One-Piece, BAYROLL Compact ADA, DeerValley DV-1F52812, and HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece all feature dual-flush mechanisms. The Casta Diva model uses air-pressure flushing instead of a traditional dual-flush button.
Which model is best for users who prefer a round seat?
The BAYROLL Compact ADA Toilet is the only model with a round bowl shape. All other alternatives in this list feature elongated bowls. The round design allows for a shorter overall length of 25.6 inches, making it suitable for very small bathroom layouts.
Is there a black option available among these alternatives?
The DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece is the only black toilet listed. It features a high gloss black finish with chrome buttons. This model is designed for standard height seating and is suitable for users seeking a dark, modern aesthetic for their bathroom.
Which alternative uses air-pressure technology for flushing?
The Casta Diva Air-Pressure ADA One-Piece uses air-pressure technology. This mechanism provides strong flushing power without requiring electricity. It is designed for ADA-accessible bathrooms and prioritizes water efficiency and performance over quiet operation, distinguishing it from the dual-flush models in this group.
How do the dimensions of these alternatives compare to the St. Tropez?
Dimensions vary significantly across the alternatives. The St. Tropez measures 27 inches in length. The BAYROLL Compact ADA is shorter at 25.6 inches, while the HOROW Compact Elongated One-Piece is longer at 28.8 inches. Widths range from 13 inches for the DeerValley Black model to 15.2 inches for the St. Tropez.