Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet or Swiss Madison Ivy One Piece Dual? Which Swiss Madison Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing the swiss madison st tropez one piece toilet vs ivy one piece dual, you will find both share a one-piece design, elongated bowls, and dual flush systems. The primary difference lies in their height and dimensions. The St. Tropez offers a comfort height seat, while the Ivy provides a standard height. Both models use similar ceramic materials and rough-in sizes, making them suitable for standard bathroom layouts.
Key differences
| Aspect | Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet | Swiss Madison Ivy One Piece Dual Flush |
|---|---|---|
| Seat Height | ADA Chair Height (Comfort Height) | Standard Height |
| Overall Height | 31.3 inches | 29 inches |
| Width | 15.2 inches | 14 inches |
| Weight | 109 pounds | 90 pounds |
| Variation Options | 10 options including Matte Black and Glossy Black | 4 options including Glossy Bisque |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet if
- You prefer a taller seat for easier sitting and standing.
- You want more color and finish choices for your bathroom.
- You do not mind a heavier unit for installation.
Choose Swiss Madison Ivy One Piece Dual Flush if
- You prefer a standard height toilet that fits typical aesthetics.
- You want a lighter unit that may be easier to handle.
- You need a narrower footprint for tighter spaces.
Verdict: The St. Tropez is better for users who need ADA-compliant seating or prefer more finish variety. The Ivy suits those who want a standard height and a lighter, narrower unit. Both provide efficient dual flushing and durable ceramic construction.
Height and Fit Comparison
Seat height comfort
The St. Tropez features ADA chair height seating. This comfort height design sits at approximately 17 to 19 inches from the floor. It reduces the need to bend deeply, making it easier for taller users or those with mobility concerns to sit and stand. The Ivy offers a standard height of about 15 to 17 inches. This lower profile suits shorter users or children better. If you prefer a traditional toilet height, the Ivy is the choice. If you want easier access, the St. Tropez is better.
Overall dimensions
Size matters in small bathrooms. The St. Tropez is larger, measuring 27 inches in length and 15.2 inches in width. The Ivy is more compact, with a length of 26 inches and a width of 14 inches. The Ivy saves about an inch in width and length. This extra space can make a noticeable difference in tight quarters. If your bathroom is narrow or cramped, the Ivy’s smaller footprint is practical. If you have ample space, the St. Tropez’s larger bowl may feel more substantial.
Weight and stability
The St. Tropez weighs 109 pounds. The Ivy weighs 90 pounds. The St. Tropez is significantly heavier. This extra mass often translates to better stability during use. A heavier toilet is less likely to shift or rock if not perfectly leveled. The Ivy is lighter, which can make installation slightly easier for one person. However, the St. Tropez feels more solid once installed. If you prioritize a heavy, stable fixture, the St. Tropez has the edge.
Flush technology
Both toilets use a dual flush system with 1.1 GPF and 1.6 GPF options. The St. Tropez specifies a Vortex flush, creating a cyclonic rinsing action. This design aims to scrub the bowl walls effectively. The Ivy lists dual flush buttons but does not specify a vortex mechanism. Both offer water efficiency. The St. Tropez’s vortex claim suggests a more aggressive cleaning action. If you want advanced rinsing technology, the St. Tropez is the better option. Otherwise, both handle waste efficiently.
Variety options
The St. Tropez offers ten variations. You can choose from multiple heights, rough-in sizes (10, 12, or 14 inches), and colors like matte black or glossy white. The Ivy offers only four variations. It supports 10 or 12-inch rough-ins and comes in glossy white, bisque, or black. The St. Tropez provides far more customization. If you need a specific rough-in size or a unique color finish, the St. Tropez gives you more choices. The Ivy is limited in this regard.
Which Swiss Madison Toilet Should You Buy
Users needing ADA compliant seating height
The St. Tropez features ADA chair height seating. This comfort height design sits at approximately 17 to 19 inches from the floor. It reduces the need to bend deeply, making it easier for taller users or those with mobility challenges. The elongated bowl adds extra room, and the one-piece ceramic construction ensures durable, non-porous surfaces that are easy to clean.
Buyers seeking a compact and lightweight unit
The Ivy model is smaller and lighter. It measures 26 inches in length and weighs 90 pounds. The St. Tropez is longer at 27 inches and heavier at 109 pounds. If your bathroom has limited floor space or you prefer a lighter fixture for installation, the Ivy’s compact dimensions and reduced weight make it a practical choice for smaller layouts.
Shoppers wanting more color and size options
The St. Tropez offers greater variety. It comes in ten variations with multiple rough-in sizes including 10, 12, and 14 inches. You can choose from glossy white, matte black, and other finishes. The Ivy model has fewer variations and limited rough-in options. If you need specific fit measurements or unique color finishes, the St. Tropez provides more configuration choices.
The products compared
Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet
Best for: ADA-compliant water-saving bathrooms
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Bowl Shape
- elongated
- Toilet Type
- one-piece
- Seat Height
- ADA Chair Height
View on Amazon: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link
This Swiss Madison St. Tropez toilet is a one-piece unit with an elongated bowl and ADA-compliant seat height. It uses a dual vortex flush system that saves water by using 1.1 gallons per flush for liquids and 1.6 gallons for solids. The glossy white ceramic body is scratch-resistant and non-porous. It fits standard 12-inch rough-in spaces and measures 27 inches in length.
Pros
- Dual vortex flush uses 1.1 or 1.6 GPF
- ADA chair height for easier sitting
- One-piece design with elongated bowl
- Scratch-resistant non-porous ceramic
Cons
- Heavy at 109 pounds
- Bulky 27-inch length
- Standard 12-inch rough-in only
Good fit if
- You need ADA-compliant seating height
- You want water-efficient dual flushing
- You have a standard 12-inch rough-in
Skip if
- You have a tight space under 27 inches
- You prefer a compact two-piece design
- You need non-standard rough-in sizes
Verdict: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet is a sturdy, water-efficient option for those who need ADA height and a low-maintenance one-piece build. It suits standard bathrooms where space allows for its 27-inch length.
Swiss Madison Ivy One Piece Dual Flush
Best for: Water-conscious users with standard height needs
- Flush Type
- dual flush
- Flush Volume
- 1.1/1.6 gpf
- Rough-In Size
- 12"
- Seat Height
- standard height
- Bowl Shape
- elongated
- Toilet Type
- one piece
View on Amazon: Swiss Madison Ivy One Piece Dual Flush Affiliate link
The Swiss Madison Ivy is a one-piece elongated toilet with a dual-flush system. It offers a 1.1 gpf light flush or a 1.6 gpf full flush. The bowl sits at a standard height of 15 to 17 inches. This glossy white ceramic unit measures 26 inches long and weighs 90 pounds. It fits a standard 12-inch rough-in. You will appreciate the scratch-resistant surface for daily use.
Pros
- Dual flush buttons for 1.1 or 1.6 gpf usage
- Elongated bowl shape for added comfort
- One-piece design with durable ceramic construction
- Standard 12-inch rough-in size compatibility
Cons
- Standard height may be less comfortable for taller users
- Heavier 90-pound build requires careful handling
- Limited color options compared to other models
Good fit if
- You prefer a one-piece design for easier cleaning
- You want to reduce water usage with dual flushing
- You have a standard 12-inch rough-in space
Skip if
- You need a comfort height toilet for easier access
- You require a compact 10-inch rough-in fit
- You prefer a taller seat height for ergonomic support
Verdict: Swiss Madison Ivy Dual Flush One-Piece Toilet provides a water-efficient, elongated option for standard bathrooms. It suits buyers who prioritize a sleek one-piece build and dual-flush savings over extra height.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet | Swiss Madison Ivy One Piece Dual Flush |
|---|---|---|
| Flush Type | dual flush | dual flush |
| Flush Volume | 1.1/1.6 GPF | 1.1/1.6 gpf |
| Rough-In Size | 12" | 12" |
| Seat Height | not stated | standard height |
| Bowl Shape | elongated | elongated |
| Toilet Type | one-piece | one piece |
| Shape | Elongated | not stated |
| Design | One Piece | One Piece |
| Dimensions | 27 × 15.2 × 31.3 inches | 26 × 14 × 29 inches |
| Weight | 109 pounds | 90 pounds |
| Size | 12" Rough-in | 12" Rough-in |
| Color | Glossy White | Glossy White |
| Model | SM-1T254 | SM-1T112 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Swiss Madison toilet is better for small bathrooms?
The Ivy One Piece Dual is the better choice for tighter spaces. It measures 26 inches in length and 14 inches in width. The St. Tropez is slightly larger at 27 inches long and 15.2 inches wide. The Ivy’s compact footprint allows it to fit more easily into smaller powder rooms or cramped layouts without crowding the area.
Does the St. Tropez require a 12-inch rough-in?
Yes, the St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet requires a standard 12-inch rough-in size. This is the most common measurement for residential bathrooms in the United States. You must ensure your wall-to-flange distance matches this specification before installation. The Ivy model also uses this standard 12-inch rough-in, so both fit typical plumbing setups.
Is the St. Tropez heavier than the Ivy model?
Yes, the St. Tropez is significantly heavier. It weighs 109 pounds, while the Ivy model weighs 90 pounds. The extra weight comes from its larger dimensions and ADA-compliant height structure. This heft can make the St. Tropez feel more solid during use, but it also requires more effort to handle during installation compared to the lighter Ivy.
Can I use dual flush on both models?
Both toilets feature dual flush systems. This allows you to choose between a lower-volume flush for liquid waste and a higher-volume flush for solid waste. This design helps conserve water by letting you select the appropriate amount of water for each use. Both the St. Tropez and Ivy models include this water-saving technology.
What is the seat height difference between them?
The St. Tropez features ADA chair height seating, which typically sits around 17 to 19 inches from the floor. The Ivy model is designed for standard height needs, sitting lower at approximately 29 inches overall. The St. Tropez’s elevated seat reduces bending, making it easier for taller users or those with mobility concerns to sit and stand.
Do both toilets come in glossy white?
Yes, both models are available in a glossy white finish. This color provides a clean, bright look that matches most bathroom decor styles. The glossy surface is also easy to wipe down and maintain. Both the St. Tropez and Ivy models share this standard aesthetic, ensuring consistency if you are upgrading multiple fixtures.
Which model is more water-efficient?
Both models are water-efficient due to their dual flush designs. You can select the flush volume based on your needs, reducing overall water consumption. The St. Tropez is specifically noted as a water-saving option for ADA-compliant bathrooms. The Ivy also prioritizes water savings for users who do not need the extra height. Both are smart choices for conservation.
Are both toilets one-piece designs?
Yes, both the St. Tropez and Ivy are one-piece toilets. This design integrates the tank and bowl into a single ceramic unit. It eliminates seams where dirt and bacteria can accumulate, making cleaning easier. The sleek, continuous shape also offers a modern look. Both models share this low-maintenance construction style.