Looking Beyond the BAYROLL One Piece Sleek Modern? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look

How each alternative compares

HOROW Compact One-Piece Toilet

The HOROW Compact One-Piece Toilet is slightly narrower at 13.4 inches wide compared to the BAYROLL model. It also sits 1.4 inches taller at 28.4 inches. This unit uses a dual flush system and includes a soft-close seat. The round bowl design keeps the footprint small for tight spaces. You get a modern look with a white finish and gold button. The 12-inch rough-in size matches standard installations. If you need a bit more height and a slimmer width, this option fits well. It offers easy cleaning surfaces similar to the BAYROLL but with a different aesthetic touch.

DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece

The DeerValley DV-1F52812 stands out with a high-gloss black finish. It is the narrowest option at just 13 inches wide. The length is 24.6 inches, making it shorter than the BAYROLL. It features a dual flush system and a one-piece design. The seat height is standard, which is lower than the BAYROLL’s 17-inch ADA-compliant height. This model weighs less at 78 pounds. You get a sleek, dark look that contrasts with typical white toilets. If you prioritize a slim profile and a specific color scheme over accessible seating, this black unit is a strong choice. It fits small bathrooms well while offering easy maintenance.

DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet

The DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet matches the BAYROLL in seat height, offering an ADA-compliant 17-inch rise. It is also narrower at 13 inches wide and shorter at 24.6 inches long. This model uses a dual flush system and includes a soft-close seat. The round bowl shape ensures it fits in very tight spaces. It weighs 86 pounds, which is lighter than the BAYROLL. The white finish provides a clean, modern appearance. If you want the same accessible height but a more compact footprint, this alternative is suitable. It delivers similar performance in a smaller package, making it ideal for secondary bathrooms or small powder rooms.

HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet

The HOROW T0338WG ADA Height One Piece is larger than the BAYROLL model. It measures 26.6 inches long and 15 inches wide. The seat height is ADA-compliant at 17 inches. It features a dual flush system and a gold button accent. The unit weighs 99.2 pounds, making it heavier than the BAYROLL. The white finish with gold hardware offers a distinct look. If you need a slightly larger bowl for more comfort while maintaining ADA compliance, this option works well. It provides a robust build and accessible seating. The extra width and length offer more room for users who find the BAYROLL too narrow or short.

Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet

The Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet features an elongated bowl, unlike the round bowl of the BAYROLL. It is taller at 31.3 inches and weighs 109 pounds. The seat height is ADA-compliant at 17 inches. It uses a dual flush system for water efficiency. The glossy white finish and modern design suit standard bathrooms. The elongated shape provides more seating comfort but requires more floor space. If you prefer an elongated bowl for added comfort and do not mind a larger footprint, this model is a good fit. It combines accessibility with a traditional toilet shape, offering a different experience than the compact round design of the BAYROLL.

DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet

The DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet offers an elongated bowl shape and ADA-compliant seating. It is 28 inches long and 14.2 inches wide. The height is 26.8 inches, slightly shorter than the BAYROLL. It features a dual flush system and a chrome button. The white finish provides a clean look. The elongated design offers more comfort for users who prefer a longer seat. It weighs 95 pounds. If you want accessible height with a larger bowl size, this alternative is suitable. It balances modern aesthetics with practical comfort. The one-piece design ensures easy cleaning, similar to the BAYROLL, but with a more traditional seating profile for everyday use.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

BAYROLL Round One-Piece Toilet

Best for: Small bathrooms needing ADA-compliant seating

Flush Type

Dual Flush

Flush Volume

0.9/1.28 GPF

Rough-In Size

12"

Seat Height

17"

Bowl Shape

round

MaP Flush Score

1000g

View on Amazon: BAYROLL Round One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link

This BAYROLL one-piece toilet features a 17-inch ADA-compliant seat height and a dual-flush system using 0.9 or 1.28 GPF. Its sleek, fully skirted design measures 25.6 inches long and 14.8 inches wide, making it suitable for small bathrooms. The unit includes a soft-close seat and achieves a MaP score of 1000g for effective waste removal. It fits standard 12-inch rough-ins.

Pros

• 17-inch ADA-compliant seat height reduces strain
• Dual-flush options at 0.9 and 1.28 GPF
• Fully skirted design simplifies cleaning
• MaP score of 1000g ensures strong flushing

Cons

• Round bowl shape is less common than elongated
• Heavier build at 93 pounds requires careful handling
• Limited to 12-inch rough-in size only

Good fit if

• You need an ADA-compliant height for accessibility
• You are installing in a small bathroom or apartment
• You want a modern, skirted design for easy cleaning

Skip if

• You require an elongated bowl shape for comfort
• Your bathroom has a rough-in size other than 12 inches
• You prefer a lighter unit for easier installation

Verdict: BAYROLL One Piece Modern Toilet, 17" ADA Height offers a compact footprint with accessible seating. It suits users prioritizing ADA compliance and easy maintenance in tight spaces.

2 Also great

HOROW Compact One-Piece Toilet

Best for: small bathrooms needing compact dimensions

Flush Type

Dual flush

Flush Volume

1.1/1.6 GPF

Rough-In Size

12"

Seat Height

16.5"

Bowl Shape

Round

Toilet Type

One-piece

View on Amazon: HOROW Compact One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link

This compact one-piece toilet measures 25 inches deep, making it suitable for small bathrooms. It features a round bowl and a 16.5-inch seat height. The dual flush system uses 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. You get a soft-closing seat and a fully glazed bowl for easy cleaning. The gold button adds a modern touch to the design.

Pros

• Compact 25-inch depth fits small spaces
• Dual flush options at 1.1 and 1.6 GPF
• 16.5-inch seat height for easier use
• Fully glazed bowl resists stains

Cons

• Round bowl shape is less common than elongated
• No remote control or automated features
• Only 1-year limited warranty included

Good fit if

• You need a toilet that fits in a tight space
• You prefer a standard round bowl shape
• You want a comfortable 16.5-inch seat height

Skip if

• You require an elongated bowl for more comfort
• You need a chair height of 17 inches or more
• You prefer a longer warranty than one year

Verdict: HOROW HWMT-8733 Compact One-Piece Toilet fits small bathrooms well with its 25-inch depth. It suits buyers who need a compact unit with a comfortable seat height and easy-to-clean surfaces.

3 Also great

DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece

Best for: small bathrooms needing a black finish

Flush Type

Dual Flush

Flush Volume

1.1/1.6 GPF

Rough-In Size

12"

Seat Height

16.5"

Bowl Shape

round

Toilet Type

one-piece

View on Amazon: DeerValley DV-1F52812 Black One-Piece Affiliate link

This DeerValley one-piece toilet features a glossy black finish and a fully skirted design for easy maintenance. It has a standard 16.5-inch seat height and a compact 13-inch width, making it suitable for small bathrooms. The dual-flush system offers 1.1 or 1.6 GPF options. It includes a soft-closing seat and fits a 12-inch rough-in. The unit weighs 78 pounds.

Pros

• Glossy black finish resists smudges
• Fully skirted design simplifies cleaning
• Soft-closing seat prevents noise
• Compact 13-inch width saves space
• Dual flush saves water

Cons

• Standard 16.5-inch seat height is not ADA compliant
• Round bowl shape is less common than elongated
• Black finish shows water spots

Good fit if

• You need a compact toilet for a small bathroom
• You prefer a modern black aesthetic
• You want easy cleaning with a skirted design

Skip if

• You require ADA-compliant chair height
• You prefer an elongated bowl shape
• You want a white toilet only

Verdict: DeerValley Compact One-Piece Toilet fits small bathrooms with its 13-inch width and standard height. It suits buyers who want a sleek black look and easy maintenance.

4 Best budget

DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet

Best for: Small bathrooms needing compact round bowl toilets

Flush Volume

1.1/1.6 GPF

Rough-In Size

12''

Bowl Shape

round

Toilet Type

one-piece

Design Style

Modern

Target Space

Small Bathrooms

View on Amazon: DeerValley Compact Round White Toilet Affiliate link

This DeerValley one-piece toilet measures 24.6 inches long and 13 inches wide, making it a strong option for small bathrooms. It features a 1.1/1.6 GPF dual flush system to conserve water and a fully skirted design for easier cleaning. The unit includes a soft-close seat and meets ADA chair height standards. You get a 12-inch rough-in fit and a 250-pound weight capacity. It is a practical choice for tight spaces.

Pros

• Compact dimensions of 24.6"L x 13"W fit small bathrooms
• Dual flush system saves water with 1.1/1.6 GPF options
• Fully skirted design eliminates crevices for easy cleaning
• Soft-close seat operates quietly at 28dB
• Includes complete installation kit with wrench and bolts

Cons

• Round bowl shape is less common than elongated styles
• Standard height may not suit all user preferences
• 12-month warranty is shorter than typical industry standards

Good fit if

• You need a toilet that fits in a tight space
• You want a fully skirted design for easy cleaning
• You prefer a round bowl shape for compactness

Skip if

• You require an elongated bowl for extra comfort
• You need a higher seat height than standard
• You want a longer warranty period than 12 months

Verdict: DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet is a space-saving solution for small bathrooms with its compact round bowl and dual flush system. It suits buyers who prioritize easy cleaning and tight space fit over elongated comfort.

5 Best premium

HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet

Best for: ADA-compliant bathroom renovations

Flush Type

Dual flush

Flush Volume

1.1/1.6 GPF

Rough-In Size

12"

Seat Height

17.3"

Bowl Shape

Elongated

MaP Flush Score

1000g

View on Amazon: HOROW T0338WG Gold Button ADA Toilet Affiliate link

The HOROW T0338WG is a one-piece toilet with an elongated bowl and ADA-compliant 17.3-inch seat height. It features a dual-flush system using 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. The unit measures 26.6 inches deep and includes a soft-closing seat. This model suits users who need accessible seating and a compact footprint for smaller bathrooms.

Pros

• ADA-compliant 17.3-inch chair height
• Dual-flush 1.1/1.6 GPF options
• Elongated bowl shape
• Soft-closing PP seat included
• Skirted trapway for easier cleaning

Cons

• Heavier at 99.2 pounds
• Gold button finish limits color matching
• Standard 1-year limited warranty only

Good fit if

• You require ADA-compliant seating height
• You need a compact one-piece design
• You want a dual-flush water-saving option

Skip if

• You prefer a standard seat height
• You need a chrome or black button finish
• You require a longer warranty period

Verdict: HOROW T0338WG ADA Height One Piece provides accessible seating and water efficiency for users who prioritize ADA compliance and a compact footprint.

6 Also great

Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet

Best for: ADA-accessible bathrooms needing water efficiency

Flush Type

dual flush

Flush Volume

1.1/1.6 GPF

Rough-In Size

12"

Bowl Shape

elongated

Toilet Type

one-piece

Seat Height

ADA Chair Height

View on Amazon: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link

The Swiss Madison St. Tropez is a one-piece elongated toilet with an ADA-compliant seat height of 17 inches. It uses a dual vortex flush system that consumes 1.1 gallons per flush for water efficiency, with a maximum of 1.6 gallons. The glossy white ceramic bowl is scratch-resistant and non-porous. This model fits standard 12-inch rough-in spaces. It suits you if you want a sleek, modern design with comfortable seating and reliable flushing performance.

Pros

• ADA-compliant 17-inch seat height for easier sitting and standing
• Dual vortex flush uses only 1.1 GPF for water savings
• One-piece design offers a sleek, modern look and easier cleaning

Cons

• Weighs 109 pounds, making installation more difficult than lighter models
• Only available in standard 12-inch rough-in size for this variation
• Lacks a soft-close seat mechanism in the provided specifications

Good fit if

• You need an ADA-compliant height for accessibility
• You prefer a one-piece design for a clean aesthetic
• You want to save water with a 1.1 GPF flush option

Skip if

• You have a non-standard rough-in size like 10 or 14 inches
• You require a heavy-duty soft-close seat included
• You prefer a compact round bowl over an elongated shape

Verdict: Swiss Madison St. Tropez One Piece combines ADA height with a water-efficient dual flush. It fits you if you prioritize accessibility and a modern, easy-to-clean one-piece design in a standard bathroom layout.

7

DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet

Best for: ADA-compliant accessibility and water efficiency

Flush Type

dual flush

Flush Volume

1.1/1.6 GPF

Rough-In Size

12"

Seat Height

17 3/8"

Bowl Shape

elongated

MaP Flush Score

800g

View on Amazon: DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet Affiliate link

This DeerValley one-piece toilet features an elongated bowl and a 17 3/8-inch ADA-compliant seat height. It uses a dual flush system with 1.1 and 1.6 GPF options. The unit includes a self-cleaning glazed surface and a skirted design. It weighs 95 pounds and fits a 12-inch rough-in. This model suits users seeking accessible height and water efficiency.

Pros

• 17 3/8-inch ADA-compliant seat height
• Dual flush system at 1.1/1.6 GPF
• Skirted design with self-cleaning glaze
• MaP flush score of 800g

Cons

• Heavier 95-pound build
• Standard 12-inch rough-in only
• No included seat cushion

Good fit if

• You need ADA-compliant seating height
• You want a skirted one-piece design
• You prioritize water-saving flush options

Skip if

• You require a standard 15-inch rough-in
• You prefer a round bowl shape
• You need a compact 10-inch rough-in

Verdict: DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet offers accessible height and efficient flushing for those who value ease of cleaning. It is a solid option for bathrooms needing ADA compliance and modern aesthetics.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions